Collection app comparison: mintboxd, Discogs, CLZ, Letterboxd
Four apps people use to keep track of a physical media collection, side by side. Short version: Discogs is music only and also a marketplace; CLZ (Collectorz) is a separate paid app per category; Letterboxd is a film diary and does not track physical editions. mintboxd keeps music, film, games, books and figures in one free app for iPhone and Android, records them at pressing level, shows them on a 3D shelf, and does not sell anything.
| Feature | mintboxd | Discogs | CLZ (Collectorz) | Letterboxd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scope | Music, film, games, books, comics, figures in one app | Music only (vinyl, CD, cassette) | Music, movies, games, books, comics, each a separate app | Film and TV only |
| Pressing-level records | Yes: format, country, year, region code, edition, catalogue number | Yes, very detailed for music | Partly (edition pick) | No, work level |
| Barcode scanning | Yes; also ISBN and game disc serial numbers | Yes (mobile app) | Yes | No |
| 3D shelf | Yes, at real case dimensions; unknown cases measured with the camera | No | No | No |
| Estimated value | Yes, from eBay listing medians | Yes, from its own marketplace data | Yes (some categories) | No |
| Diary, ratings, reviews | Yes | Limited (ratings and comments) | Limited | Yes, core feature |
| Social | Follow, feed, reels, likes, comments, messages; private profile option | Forum, shared collections | No | Follow, lists, comments |
| Marketplace | No; no selling or payments | Yes, buying, selling and fees | No | No |
| Price | Free, no ads | Free (seller fees) | Paid subscription | Free; Pro and Patron paid |
| Platform | iPhone and iPad (iOS 17+), Android 8.0+ | Web, iOS, Android | Web, iOS, Android | Web, iOS, Android |
| Languages | English, Turkish, German, Spanish, Italian, Arabic, Japanese | Multilingual | Multilingual | Multilingual |
Which one is for whom
- You collect only vinyl and CDs and you buy and sell: Discogs. It has the largest music catalogue and a marketplace.
- You manage several categories from a desktop and will pay for it: CLZ. Each category is a separate app and subscription.
- You want to log and rate the films you watch: Letterboxd. No physical editions, barcodes or shelf.
- You want vinyl, film, games, books and figures in one place, at pressing level, on a 3D shelf: mintboxd. No selling; available on iOS and Android.
mintboxd vs Discogs
Both record music at pressing level; mintboxd actually uses Discogs data for music matching. The difference is scope and purpose: Discogs is music only and a marketplace; mintboxd also covers film, games, books and figures, sells nothing, and shows the collection on a 3D shelf.
mintboxd vs CLZ
CLZ needs a separate app and paid subscription per category and also runs on web and Android. mintboxd keeps every category in one free app and adds a social feed and a 3D shelf, and runs on iOS and Android.
mintboxd vs Letterboxd
Letterboxd records what you watched; mintboxd records what you own. Letterboxd's diary and social features are very strong, and it has no physical editions, barcodes or shelf. mintboxd has a diary and ratings too, but the object in your hands is the centre.